Ending a marriage is rarely simple, even when you and your spouse agree you should move on. New York’s no-fault divorce law lets couples end their marriage without proving wrongdoing. However, that doesn’t mean the process is automatically straightforward. As a Pittsford no-fault divorce lawyer, Michelle Cimino helps clients navigate the divorce process while addressing important concerns about property, finances, and family.
Here are the top questions to ask an attorney, like Michelle Cimino, about the no-fault process.
Do I Need To Prove Fault To File for Divorce in New York?
What are the grounds for divorce in New York State? Since 2010, New York has had no-fault divorce, meaning you don’t have to prove wrongdoing, such as adultery or abandonment, to establish grounds for divorce (New York Domestic Relations Law § 170(7)).
Instead, one spouse must state under oath that the marriage has broken down irretrievably for at least six months. You do not have to live separately to use this ground.
What Must My Spouse and I Resolve Before Finalizing Our No-Fault Divorce?
Before a New York court can finalize your no-fault divorce, all applicable financial and child-related issues must be resolved by agreement or decided by the court, including:
- Division of marital property and responsibility for marital debts
- Payment or waiver of spousal support (alimony)
- Child custody and parenting time (visitation)
- Child support
- Responsibility for attorney fees, expert fees, and related expenses
If you and your spouse can’t reach an agreement, a court can decide disputed issues. Regardless, the resolution of these issues must be incorporated into the divorce judgment before the court can grant your no-fault divorce.
Is a No-Fault Divorce Uncontested?
No, a no-fault divorce is not automatically uncontested in New York. These terms describe different aspects of the divorce.
No-fault refers to the legal reason for ending the marriage. Uncontested means the divorcing spouses have no disputed issues. A divorce could be no-fault but not uncontested, and vice versa.
For instance, you and your spouse may agree that the marriage is over but disagree about who keeps the house or how to share parenting time. In this situation, your divorce could proceed on no-fault grounds while those issues remain contested.
Which Court Would Handle My Divorce?
If you live in Pittsford and file for divorce locally, the Monroe County Supreme Court would handle your case. The courthouse is located at the Hall of Justice at 99 Exchange Boulevard in downtown Rochester. The court handles both contested and uncontested divorces.
In New York, only Supreme Court has the authority to grant a divorce. Family Court can handle certain related matters, including child custody, visitation, and support, but it cannot grant a divorce.
You may not need to appear in court at all, particularly if your divorce is uncontested and all required paperwork is properly completed. However, if you do need to appear to file for divorce in Monroe County, it would generally be at the Monroe County Supreme Court.
What Should I Bring to My First Meeting With a Pittsford No-Fault Divorce Lawyer?
Bring any available documents that give your lawyer a clear picture of your marriage, finances, and concerns, including:
- Recent tax returns, pay stubs, and statements for bank and retirement accounts
- A list of major assets and debts, including your home, mortgage, and credit card balances
- Any prenuptial, postnuptial, or separation agreement
- Any divorce papers or existing custody, support, or protection orders
- If you have children, notes about their needs and your current parenting arrangements
You do not need every document before seeking advice. Bring what you have, and ask the lawyer’s office whether it has a specific checklist for your consultation.
Bring Your Questions to a Pittsford No-Fault Divorce Lawyer
No-fault divorce may simplify the legal grounds for ending a marriage, but it doesn’t eliminate the important decisions that come with it. From dividing marital property to determining child custody and financial support, the choices you make during divorce can affect your life long after the process ends. You deserve to understand your options before you decide. Michelle Cimino can help you understand the legal process and what to expect.
Reach out to schedule a confidential consultation today.

